Fashion & Beauty

Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement. Julius Pinschewer and Rudi Klemm s Die chinesische Nachtigall 1.

Published
of 12
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
Share
Description
Michael Cowan Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement. Julius Pinschewer and Rudi Klemm s Die chinesische Nachtigall 1. Introduction With the emerging scholarship on sponsored and ephemeral films,
Transcript
Michael Cowan Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement. Julius Pinschewer and Rudi Klemm s Die chinesische Nachtigall 1. Introduction With the emerging scholarship on sponsored and ephemeral films, the discipline of film studies has been undergoing something of a paradigm shift. No longer taking feature films and featurelength documentary as the standard, historians are rediscovering entire worlds of moving image culture long forgotten in the vaults of corporations, advertising agencies and educational institutions. Much of the debate in recent scholarship has accordingly revolved around the question of how to treat this newfound material. Ought we to examine individual films or only consider entire corpuses? And what constitutes a single corpus when dealing with such fluid categories as industrial and advertising film? Above all, what value can formal or aesthetic analysis have for the study of films that were made under different auspices and followed a different set of rules from those of feature films? In one influential approach to these questions, Thomas Elsaesser has argued that scholars of sponsored and ephemeral films should attend to what he calls the three As, examining who commissioned the work (Auftrag), for what occasion or purpose (Anlass) and for what audience (Adressat). 2 In many ways, this argument to foreground the specific economic context of these films production, distribution and reception echoes the demands of early advertising theorists themselves, who repeatedly stressed the need to subordinate aesthetics in advertising images traditionally understood as the realm of disinterested contemplation to the immediate and interested concerns of economic efficacy. 3 But this is not to say that advertisers took no interest in the formal properties of advertising images. On the contrary, it would be hard to think of a realm of early 20 th century visual culture in which questions of form played such a seminal role as that of advertising, bound up as it was with practices and discourses of design. Moreover, as one can gather by the enormous amounts of time and energy that advertising theorists expended testing every possible aspect of image design from size to layout to color and brightness, the centrality of formal questions stemmed precisely from the economic constraints within which advertising images were produced. 4 This concern with advertising design extended, of course, to advertising film, which overwhelmingly privileged graphic and experimental forms of animation and montage and, in Germany as in Russia, attracted the participation of experimental filmmakers. 5 In this article, I want to explore this imbrication of form and context while focusing on the celebrated advertising film Die chinesische Nachtigall (1929) by Julius Pinschewer and animator Rudi Klemm. Still remembered today as the first sound-film advertisement, the seven-minute film was also an advertisement for sound film technologies: namely the new Tri-Ergon system of optical sound (or sound-on-film ) recording, which promised to replace older forms of mechanical needle recording with photographic sound inscription. In order to tout the superiority of the new system the filmmakers rewrote Hans Christian Andersen s famous tale The Nightingale to tell the story of a Chinese emperor who offers his daughter in marriage to whomever can most faithfully reproduce the nightengale s beautiful song. After hearing from an old and plump Herr Trichter (Mr. Horn) and a young and dashing Tri-Ergo, the emperor crowns 90 Michael Cowan, Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement Tri-Ergon technologies the winner and the film declares the superiority of filming sound over previous methods of mechanical inscription. In unpacking the formal and rhetorical strategies of Die chinesische Nachtigall, my point is not to pit aesthetic analysis against contextualization, but rather to show how the film s complex aesthetics respond precisely to its economic, technological and cultural context(s). As I will show, the film offers a fascinating example of advertising aesthetics because of the way in which it combines several of the typical formal strategies of advertising film. This aesthetic dialogism, I argue, along with the film s narrative structure, can be tied back not only to its status as an advertisement for new sound technologies, but also to a fundamental ambiguity about those technologies themselves. Here as elsewhere, then, contextual factors are crucial not as an alternative to aesthetics, but as a prerequisite for understanding the film s formal strategies. In the case of Die chinesische Nachtigall, those factors situate the film at a critical juncture in the history of sound technology. Emerging after WWI, the Tri-Ergon optical sound recording process was, in fact, one of several competing systems for producing sound film by But by insisting on the Tri-Ergon system s superior fidelity to an original, Pinschewer and Klemm s film in fact takes up a rhetorical trope that had surrounded sound technologies from the late 19 th century onward. It would be a mistake to understand the category of fidelity deterministically as an inherent quality of technological media themselves. Rather, as Jonathan Sterne has argued, the discourse on fidelity had much more to do with a process of cultural training; beginning in the second half of the 19 th century, media consumers were increasingly taught above all by advertisements such as that for the Victrola orthophonic phonograph to conceive of sound technology as a vanishing mediator, a process in which each new media technology rendered the noise of the previous technology audible. 6 This is precisely the model we see in Pinschewer and Klemm s Nightingale film when the emperor, who demands to hear a perfect reproduction of nightingale s song so wie er mir in der Mondnacht erklang rejects Herr Trichter s recording on account of the audible crackling sound ( Deine Platte knarrt! ) and praises Tri-Ergon for its ability to render the nightengale s song as if the bird itself were present. Although crucial to the development of integrated film soundtracks, the new technology of optical sound recording in which sound is transformed into light and inscribed on the filmstrip either as differing shades of gray or as a series of black teeth-like figures of varying heights and widths also took part in a broader shift in sound technology in the 1920s that extended far beyond film. Spurred on by developments in radio, companies such as Victrola switched from mechanical to electric sound recording, which allowed for a wider frequency spectrum and greater amplification than mechanical recordings via horn and needle inscription. 7 This broader context helps to explain not only the terms of the emperor s competition in Die chinesische Nachtigall (e.g. horn and needle vs. optical recording), but also an ambiguity concerning the product being advertised in the film, which in fact encompasses not only sound film, but also the use of optical recording for producing phonographic records. Although the audience of Pinschewer and Klemm s film sees the production of a sound filmstrip, the emperor himself only hears a record, and the final shots of the film celebrate the record rather than the filmstrip. 8 This ambiguity concerning the product also speaks to ambiguity concerning the intended addressees of Die chinesische Nachtigall. While we know relatively little about the film s actual distribution, one can surmise that it would, in fact, have been relatively limited simply on account of the low number of movie theaters equipped with sound-film technology at the time. Moreover, while lay audiences might have been in a position to purchase gramophone recordings, they could hardly zeitgeschichte 2 / 41. Jahrgang / afford sound films, let alone optical sound recording technology. On the other hand, the film did receive widespread acclaim among professionals from the advertising industry, even winning a prize at the 1929 Weltreklamekongress in Berlin, which suggests that it was at least in part aimed at industry experts themselves. 9 Two Aesthetic Forms As an advertisement for faithful sound reproduction, Pinschewer and Klemm s film displays little interest in the well-known avant-garde debates of the late 1920s concerning the relative value of synchronized sound vs. counterpoint, and it should come as no surprise to find a relatively stable relation between the visual action and the voice-over narration. Turning our attention to the visual level, however, we find a different story. Die chinesische Nachtigall is, in fact, constructed from two distinct formal strategies, both of them already familiar from previous films produced by Pinschewer himself. On the one hand, it employs silhouette animation, a form made famous by Lotte Reiniger and also used frequently for advertising films (including several films made by Reiniger for Pinschewer s company), where its delicate and ornamental features were considered particularly appropriate in the words of one theorist from the time for leicht graziöse Dinge wie Parfüm, Blumen, zarte Gewebe, Konfekt. 10 Figure 1: Still from Die Barcarole (Lotte Reiniger and Julius Pinschewer, 1924) Such a usage and the silhouette s association with women in particular stretches back beyond advertising film into print traditions, where graphic artists such as Adelheid Schimz and Käthe Wolff made silhouette advertisements for chocolate, perfume, champagne and clothing. 11 But the silhouette was also consistently associated in films such as Reiniger s Die Abenteuer des Prinzen Achmed (1926), but also in advertising films such as Pinschewer s perfume advertisement Khasana das Tempelmädchen (1924) with a fictionalized Orient understood as the embodiment of extreme refinement and delicacy. 92 Michael Cowan, Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement Figure 2: Still from Khasana, das Tempelmädchen (Toni Raboldt and Julius Pinschewer, 1923) These associations of the silhouette with feminine delicacy and oriental refinement might seem like an odd choice for an advertisement on a new technology, but they were no doubt useful precisely for the film s argument about fidelity i.e. the ability of Tri-Ergon technology to reproduce faithfully the delicate (zärtlich) and sweet (süß) song of the nightingale. However, if Die chinesische Nachtigall takes up this association of the silhouette with delicacy, the film also counters it, at several points, with a very different aesthetic consisting of analogue photographic images. More specifically, the directors used a technique of in-camera montage that had been recently developed by Guido Seeber to create filmic collages in which several fields of moving images play out simultaneously on the screen. 12 Seeber first used such simultaneous or conceptual montages in his 1925 advertisement for the Kipho exhibition of the film and photography industries, and it is hardly by chance if the technique recalled as Seeber himself pointed out the kinds of multiplied images familiar from Fernand Léger s Ballet mécanique (1924). 13 Figure 3: Still from Kipho-Film (Guido Seeber and Julius Pinschewer, 1925) zeitgeschichte 2 / 41. Jahrgang / For Kipho was all about presenting the film industry in terms of mechanics: as an efficient industrial apparatus of interlocking gears and loops on the screen. 14 A similar function is at work in Die chinesische Nachtigall when the technique of the simultaneous image is mobilized to present the technological operations in the Tri-Ergon factory, from the recording phase to sound-film production to the pressing of records. Figure 4: Still from Die chinesische Nachtigall (Rudi Klemm and Julius Pinschewer, 1929) Combining animation with live action was, in fact, an ever-expanding technique of advertising film of the late 1920s, when companies often boasted their ability to produce films in the so-called Kombinationsverfahren to composite animated figures with live-action background. (Reiniger herself used the technique in her 1928 short Grotesken im Schnee). But Die chinesische Nachtigall differs from these attempts in the way in which it functions to confront rather than combine or composite montage and silhouette aesthetics. In so doing, the film suggests again and again the ability of technology in its montage presentation to master the delicate aesthetics of silhouette. Ideologically, such a narrative constitutes a complete reversal of Andersen s tale, which offered a romantic critique of technology in favor of a more humble relation to nature. There, as readers will remember, the Chinese emperor replaces the nightingale with a mechanical double one not a little reminiscent of the famous automata of the 18th century such as Jacques Vaucanson s digesting duck or his flute player that soon breaks down when it loses a spring. 15 By the time Pinschewer and Klemm set out to make Die chinesische Nachtigall, Andersen s tale had already been adapted several times, including a stage version by Igor Stravinsky and, most recently, a silhouette adaptation by Reiniger from But Pinschewer and Klemm s adaptation differed from previous versions by the way in which it turned Andersen s romantic critique of technology completely on its head; far from revealing technology as a poor substitute for nature, Pinschewer and Klemm s advertising film celebrates the new electric recording technologies as a means of capturing nature and rendering it controllable. Thus even as the filmmakers explicitly write Andersen s haughty mechanical bird out of the story, the film nonetheless recuperates technology in the form of the optical-sound system, which now appears as a very desirable means of reproducing nature for repeated listening on the record or the filmstrip. Here, too, one would do best to avoid any strict technological determinism. For ideas about capture, storage and preservation attached to media such as phonography and film were not 94 Michael Cowan, Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement simply neutral descriptors of inherent technological capacities. Rather, they were thoroughly embedded within the colonial and imperial contexts of the late 19 th and early 20 th centuries, in which storage media were understood as the prerogative of European anthropologists who would collect and salvage other cultures and disappearing ways of life. 16 Such colonial associations are evoked in Die chinesische Nachtigall when again in distinction to Andersen s story the film s narrator explicitly designates the two contestants and their technologies as European. Indeed, not only does the film take up a classic motif of colonialist literature in recounting the conquest of the emperor s daughter by European adventurers, it also repeatedly juxtaposes European technologies of automation to Oriental technologies of the hand. Most obviously, the emperor s hand net (Handnetz), with which he tries in vain to capture the nightingale at the beginning of the film, is replaced by the phonographic horn and ultimately by the Tri-Ergon sound camera capture system. Similarly, the image of the Chinese court, with its army of courtly attendants, is countered graphically in the film by that of the Tri-Ergon factory, with its automated production process. And this graphic opposition of spaces implies an opposition of media: Whereas the emperor s written proclamation announcing the contest has to be carried by hand throughout the realm, automated media, as we know, were consistently understood in terms of their ability to overcome the human body and the limitations of distance to which it was subject just as the Europeans in the film appear to move with ease between Europe and China. Finally, the Eastern system of writing on light specifically the lanterns carrying the emperor s orders is replaced by the automatic light-writing of the Tri-Ergon technology, by which the bird s song is transformed into a record and a series of graphic inscriptions on the film soundtrack. Figure 5: Still from Die chinesische Nachtigall It is precisely in relation to these new technologies of automatic recording that Seeber s simultaneous collage image makes its appearance, quite literally enframing the nightingale and silhouette animation on the screen. Silhouettes were, in fact, associated in the scholarship of the 1920s with the kind of oriental lantern art seen in the film, 17 and as much as Die chinesische Nachtigall is about sound, it is also about light specifically about the opposition between the sweet and delicate light of the lanterns and the electric light of the Tri-Ergon technology. But the nightingale in the film is also associated, repeatedly, with the soft light of the moon in numerous shots that frame the bird as a silhouette over the background of the full moon s circle. zeitgeschichte 2 / 41. Jahrgang / Figure 6: Still from Die chinesische Nachtigall The romantic motif par excellence, moonlight had often figured as an object of critique in modernist techno-fantasies such as those of Italian futurism, with its constant calls to kill the moonlight through a cult of electricity. 18 For all its typically Weimaresque humour, Die chinesische Nachtigal reactivates such modernist fantasies in its celebration of electricity, which is not only mentioned on the soundtrack ( auf dem Weg der Elektrizität ) as the power at the heart of the Tri-Ergon factory, but also forms part of the all-important logo presentation at the end of the film, in which the words Tri-Ergon are literally inscribed into a triangle by electric surges on the screen. Visualizing Sound The technological pathos informing the narrative of capture in Die chinesische Nachtigall might seem surprising when we recall that the phenomenon of optical sound technology itself appeared as anything but a rational process. Although first patented in Germany in 1919 by Josef Engl, Hans Vogt and Joseph Massolle, the technology by which sounds were transformed into patterns of light and dark via a photosensitive selenium cell had been the object of experimentation since at least the turn of the century. By the time Die chinesische Nachtigall was made, there existed, in fact, two systems for producing sound-on-film. One, known as Amplitudenschrift, Transversalschrift or Zackenschrift, entailed the production of a series of sawtooth-like patterns, whose width and height corresponded to the volume and quality of the recorded sounds. The other, known as Sprossenschrift or Intensitätsschrift and used by Tri-Ergon appeared as a series of rectangles in varying shades of white, black and grey Michael Cowan, Fidelity, Capture and the Sound Advertisement Figure 7: Illustration of two systems for sound-on-film, from Hans Wollenberg, Der Tonfilm. Grundlagen und Praxis seiner Aufnahme und Widergabe. Berlin 1930, 222 Both systems, however, involved a fundamentally mysterious conversion of sound waves into light and back again via electricity. As Corinna Müller has documented, around the time of sound film s emergence in the late 1920s, countless commentators saw the process by which the nuanced timbres of the human voice or the complex clusters of sound emitted by a large orchestra could be translated into a set of graphic forms as a fantastical phenomenon. 20 Thus Siegfried Kracauer described the impalpable operations of optical sound transformations as a form of magic, an esotericism of technology (Esoterik der Technik) that surpassed the Eleusinian mysteries. 21 Die chinesische Nachtigall, while offering up rudimentary explanations of the new sound-on-film process still emphasizes this sense of mystery when the narrator describes the operations of the Tri-Ergon factory as occurring auf höchst geheimnisvolle Art. As Thomas Levin has shown, such a mysterious power of electrical sound-image conversion in fact nourished the imagination of animators and engineers acro
Search
Similar documents
View more...
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks