Terrorism, Development & Trade: Winning the War on Terror Without the War

of 46
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
American University International Law Review Volume 19 Issue 3 Article Terrorism, Development & Trade: Winning the War on Terror Without the War Kevin J. Fandl Follow this and additional works at:
American University International Law Review Volume 19 Issue 3 Article Terrorism, Development & Trade: Winning the War on Terror Without the War Kevin J. Fandl Follow this and additional works at: Part of the International Law Commons Recommended Citation Fandl, Kevin J. Terrorism, Development & Trade: Winning the War on Terror Without the War. American University International Law Review 19, no. 3 (2003): This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Washington College of Law Journals & Law Reviews at Digital American University Washington College of Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in American University International Law Review by an authorized administrator of Digital American University Washington College of Law. For more information, please contact TERRORISM, DEVELOPMENT & TRADE: WINNING THE WAR ON TERROR WITHOUT THE WAR KEVIN J. FANDL IN TR O D U CTION I. UNCOVERING THE ROOTS OF TERRORISM IN THE M ID D LE EA ST II. DISPARITIES OF WEALTH AND POLITICS WITHIN TERRORIST ORGANIZATIONS III. FIGHTING THE RIGHT WAR: ATTACKING POVERTY INSTEAD OF PEOPLE A. THE POVERTY APPROACH B. EMPLOYING THE BEST WEAPON FOR THE TASK IV. STRIKING AT THE TERRORIST TARGETS WITH AID AND T R A D E A. AID AGENCIES AT THE FRONT LINES B. ERADICATING TERROR WITH TRADE V. THE BIG GUNS: MULTILATERALS AND THE WTO A. GROWTH THROUGH WORLD TRADE B. REGIONAL AGREEMENTS AND THE MEFTA C. GROWTH THROUGH FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT CONCLUDING REMARKS ON ENGAGING THE ENEMY * Admitted to practice law in New York and Massachusetts; B.A., Lock Haven University of Pennsylvania, M.A., American University School of International Service, J.D., American University Washington College of Law. Presidential Management Fellow and International Trade Specialist with U.S. Customs and Border Protection. I would like to thank my wife, Monica Bibiana Lugo, for her unending love and support and continual reminder that without human rights, there can be no fair trade. I would also like to thank Padideh Ala'i for her invaluable advisement and guidance in the development of this article and of my fascination with international trade law. I remain available to discuss this and related topics at any time via at 587 588 AM. U. INT'L L. REv. [19:587 INTRODUCTION Globalization has been blamed for a number of ills in the world. It has been argued that globalization caused the increasing gap between rich and poor, degradation of environmental resources, domestic and international violence, and even terrorism.' Globalization has also been credited with an equally significant number of advances in the world. These advances include providing increased access to education, awareness and publicity of human rights violations in all regions of the world, and improved inter-cultural understanding. 2 Regardless of one's stance on globalization, it is a concept that cannot be ignored. Terrorism, 3 especially of late, impacts our lives routinely and took much of the world by surprise in recent years with its effect on political and social relations. Recent terrorist attacks have been hailed as representative of a policy of hatred toward the West, hatred toward capitalism, and hatred toward globalization. 4 Many argue that 1. See generally Arthur C. Helton & Dessie P. Zagorcheva, Globalization, Terror and the Movements of People, 36 INTL. LAW. 91 (2002) (noting that the links between globalization and terrorism are not fully understood, but that analysts have warned that globalization can contribute to terrorism). 2. See KOFI A. ANNAN, WE THE PEOPLES: THE ROLE OF THE UNITED NATIONS IN THE 21 ST CENTURY 9, U.N. Doc. DPU2103, U.N. Sales No. E (2000) (stating that [t]he benefits of globalization are plain to see: faster economic growth, higher living standards, accelerated innovation and diffusion of technology and management skills, new economic opportunities for individuals and countries alike. ), (last visited Feb. 12, 2004). 3. See REX A. HUDSON, WHO BECOMES A TERRORIST AND WHY: THE 1999 GOVERNMENT REPORT ON PROFILING TERRORISTS 17 (The Lyons Press 1999) (defining the term terrorism ). According to the terrorist profile guide published by the U.S. Library of Congress, terrorism is defined as follows: [u]nable to achieve their unrealistic goals by conventional means, international terrorists attempt to send an ideological or religious message by terrorizing the general public. Through the choice of their targets, which are often symbolic or representative of the targeted nation, terrorists attempt to create a high-profile impact on the public of their targeted enemy or enemies with their act of violence, despite the limited material resources that are usually at their disposal. Id. 4. See, e.g., Sanam F. Vakil, The Great Leap Backward: Review of Barry Rubin: The Tragedy of the Middle East, 27 FLETCHER F. WORLD AFF. 209, 2004] TERRORISM, DEVELOPMENT & TRADE 589 the beginnings of modem terrorism are found in poverty, religion, and envy. And like globalization, one cannot ignore terrorism. The aftermath of the September 11, 2001 events created a new atmosphere of fear and vengeance, imposed upon the world primarily by the United States and Britain. 6 Hidden in this fear is a severe misunderstanding about the cause of terrorism, its remarkable ties to globalization, and the painfully underutilized solution to eradicating it as a means of political or social expression. In this essay, I argue that the roots of recent forms of international terrorism, primarily those based in the Middle East, are planted in an impoverished and ill-nurtured soil. 7 By examining the market structure and economic development of countries where recent terrorist activity has greatly increased, I contend that we will uncover a region poisoned with incomplete or inadequate development, limited employment opportunities, and infrequent interaction with both people from other cultures and potential trading partners. 8 I suggest that much of this lack of development is caused by the absence of real markets, and the inability to sustain trade with commodities other than oil and, in effect, a failure to effectively globalize. 9 (2003) (book review) (discussing recent terrorist attacks in the Middle East and the region's disappointment with democracy and angry perceptions of an overly involved United States). 5. Interview by Neal Conan with Edward Walker, President, Middle East Institute (June 3, 2003) [hereinafter Walker Interview] (defining the effects of a socio-economic crisis on the growth of terrorism in the Middle East), at (last visited Feb. 12, 2004). 6. See Shibley Telhami, Conflicting Views of Terrorism, 35 CORNELL INT'L L.J. 581, (2002) (discussing the worldwide empathy expressed to the United States after September 1 th and the controversial U.S. attempts to combat the supply side of terrorism). 7. See discussion infra Part I (discussing the roots of terrorism and economic disparity in the Middle East). 8. See infra Part I (exploring the economic realities in the Middle East with an emphasis on the effects of the oil market and economic under-development on the states in the Middle East). 9. See infra Part I (describing the area's oil economy and exploring how it relates to social stability). 590 AM. U. INT'L L. REV. [19:587 My approach consists of five steps. First, I identify the reasons why most recent terrorist attacks against the West have originated in the Middle East. 10 I briefly explore the common characteristics of terrorist recruits, including their class, opportunities and religious beliefs, and then I discuss why these characteristics play such a crucial role in the war on terror.i' Second, I proffer a viable solution that the United States and many scholars recognize, but which is surprisingly absent from contemporary U.S. foreign policy.' 2 This section concentrates on the awareness of, and pushes for the implementation of development programs aimed at market stabilization, judicial reform, and employment growth as viable weapons against terrorist recruiters. 3 Specifically, I draw parallels between current approaches to fighting terrorism, increased violence, and regional instability. 4 Third, I assess the role that investment from foreign aid agencies, investment banks, and corporations play in restoring the Middle East to a center of growth and enlightenment. 5 This section also examines the role that free trade agreements and trade unions have played in the region. 6 Fourth, I discuss the role of the World Trade Organization ( WTO ), by far the most noticeable beacon of globalization and market development. 7 This section addresses the potential role of 10. See infra Part I (explaining the current economic crisis in the Middle East region). 11. See infra Part I.A (defining common characteristics and possible motivations of terrorist recruits). 12. See infra Part II (exploring the possible use of developmental aid as a means of deterring terrorism). 13. See infra Part II.A (discussing the benefits of market, judicial and employment development programs in the Middle East). 14. See infra Part II.B (reporting the results of current approaches to fighting terrorism). 15. See discussion infra Part III.A (discussing the issues and implications surrounding investment and foreign aid in the Middle East). 16. See infra Part III.B (exploring the economic and social impact of trade agreements in the region). 17. See discussion infra Part IV (generally describing the developmental role of the WTO). 2004] TERRORISM, DEVELOPMENT & TRADE such an agency in reshaping once powerful economies and the unusual absence and antipathy of Middle Eastern actors toward joining the world's largest international marketplace. 18 Finally, I conclude by offering a strategy for approaching the terrorist dilemma by shifting the U.S. focus away from military might and toward investment and market development.' 9 My argument, while not profound, suggests that the increased involvement of the WTO, multinational corporations, international aid agencies, non-governmental organizations, and foreign investors focusing on the development of non-oil industries through a process of market diversification and stabilization will improve the lives of those living in the Middle East. I further contend that the increased involvement of these bodies will lessen or eliminate the frequency of terrorist attacks emanating from the region. 0 I. UNCOVERING THE ROOTS OF TERRORISM IN THE MIDDLE EAST Terrorism is not a novel concept. 1 It did not begin on September 11, 2001, nor will it end with the U.S. campaign against terror. Terrorism is in one sense an act of political expression, which generates grand-scale public attention to a particular group or cause. Yet, in another sense, it is an expression of despair and desperation for a better way of life. 2 This despair leads to terrorism in large part because of an all too familiar word--oil See infra Part IV.A (exploring the membership reluctance and possible impact of the WTO on the Middle East). 19. See discussion infra Part V (arguing that investment and market development will more successfully control the growth of terrorism in the Middle East). 20. See infra Part I-V (discussing the inverse effect that economic development would impose on the growth of terrorism in the Middle East). 21. See generally Sharon Harzenski, Terrorism, A History: Stage One, 12 J. TRANSNAT'L L. & POL'Y 137 (2003) (providing a history of terrorism beginning with the French Revolution). 22. See Vakil, supra note 4, at 209 (arguing that socio-economic difficulties in the Middle East are the foundations of terrorism in the region). 23. See id. at 211 (addressing the disparaging effect the oil market had on the development of Middle Eastern countries). AM. U. INT'L L. REV. [19:587 The Middle East was not a haven to terrorists prior to its discovery of oil in the early twentieth century. It was at this moment that their national economies shifted from diverse agricultural and textile markets to single-commodity exporters. 24 The dependency on oil as a primary export grew rapidly, as did the wealth accumulated by the grand kingdoms of oil moguls. Those who could not enlist in the black gold industry were quickly sifted out and left with minimal opportunity for their own development. This led to the current economic crisis in the region, marked by severe unemployment and little or no opportunity for the development of competitive and sustainable industries other than oil, an industry that in itself is losing significant ground. 25 The result was a society unable to modernize, unable to grow, and unable to join the world market. Citizens were left with little opportunity to earn a living and developing significant anger toward those profiting from the otherwise expanding global market. Edward Walker from the Middle East Institute recently said: When you've got unemployment rates running around [twenty] percent in many of the Arab countries, it means that young people who are graduating from universities can't get jobs, and in that society, it means they can't get married. It means they're frustrated, and it tends to lead to radicalization of the younger people in these countries. Some of them, at least, in that context, will turn to terrorism. So economic stability, economic opportunity is part and parcel-has got to be a part and parcel of the war on terrorism See generally Central Intelligence Agency, The World Factbook. Saudi Arabia (2002) [hereinafter World Factbook] (stating that in Saudi Arabia, in the 1930's, the discovery of oil transformed the country. ), at (last visited Feb. 12, 2004). 25. See, e.g., Vakil, supra note 4, at 211 (indicating that [f]or a time, oil revenues were able to mask economic mismanagement and fiscal profligacy. But with the decline of oil revenues in the early 1980s came the glaring reality of regional disparity highlighted by the lack of economic development. ). See generally NASA Ctr. for Educ. Technologies, Economic Growth and Decline [hereinafter Economic Growth] (showing the deleterious effects of a growing population and a shrinking export price for oil), at (last visited Jan. 22, 2004). 26. See Walker Interview, supra note 5 (identifying that unemployment fosters the participation in terrorism). 2004] TERRORISM, DEVELOPMENT & TRADE 593 Therein lays the problem. The discovery of oil led to a singlecommodity industry for many countries in the Middle East. 27 This has prevented the development of a diverse array of industries that would allow these countries to be sustainable and competitive in the global marketplace and to enjoy more opportunity for growth in their home markets. 28 The reliance on oil as a primary export has left these budding economies to the whims of the fluctuating oil markets, which rise and fall with little predictability. 9 Those left without access to wealth or opportunity are left jobless, desperate, and susceptible to terrorist recruitment. 0 II. DISPARITIES OF WEALTH AND POLITICS WITHIN TERRORIST ORGANIZATIONS Acts of terror throughout Lebanon, Palestine, and Saudi Arabia are increasing in frequency. 3 ' And, while each terrorist group has its own 27. See Interview by Neal Conan with Charlene Barshefsky, Former U.S. Trade Representative (June 3, 2003) ( This is a very fragmented region. It is largely isolated from the global economy, despite oil, or to put it another way, oil is the only connection between the Middle East, particularly the Muslim Middle East, and the global economy. ), at (last visited Feb. 12, 2004). 28. See id. (explaining the limited market opportunities available in the Middle East). 29. See Economic Growth, supra note 25, at 2 (finding that the discovery of oil wealth created disparity within both producing and non-producing Middle Eastern countries). 30. See, e.g., Hudson, supra note 3, at 77 (suggesting that while many terrorist groups find their recruits among middle-class professionals, Islamic terrorist organizations tend to include substantial numbers of poor people, many of them homeless refugees ). I do not support the idea that poverty alone creates potential terrorists, which in effect would multiply the battleground in the war on terror tenfold or more. See, e.g., The National Security Strategy of the United States of America (Sept. 2002) (quoting President Bush's contention that [p]overty does not make poor people into terrorists and murderers. Yet poverty, weak institutions, and corruption can make weak states vulnerable to terrorist networks... within their borders. ), available at (last visited Jan. 22, 2004). 31. See, e.g., Lucien J. Dhooge, A Previously Unimaginable Risk Potential: September 11 and the Insurance Industry, 40 AM. Bus. L.J. 687, (2003) (discussing the series of attacks by al Qaeda since 1993 and the increase in casualties beginning with the September 1 th, 2001 attacks). AM. U. INT'L L. REv. [19:587 method of achieving its goals, each shares the common recruitment practice of seeking members from poor areas who have limited opportunities to support themselves. 32 Poverty is rampant in rank and file Muslim terrorists; however, it is not found in the leadership of these groups. 33 So while the large majority of members of terrorist groups hail from impoverished areas in the Middle East and Southern Asia that do not afford sufficient opportunities for members' self sufficiency, 34 the wealthy leadership continue to belong to an old tradition in which self-serving elites seize upon and manipulate the grievances of the poor. 35 By manipulating ideas and subsequently the minds of individuals, these power-hungry leaders are able to seize upon the lack of opportunity of these often impoverished and otherwise peaceful citizens, convincing them to rise up and take the lives of others and/or themselves in the name of the leadership's cause-not Islam, but vengeance. 3 6 The members of these groups are not natural-born terrorists. They were born into societies with little opportunity and no chance of making a better life for themselves. 37 Intertwined with these 32. See Hudson, supra note 3, at (explaining the recruiting practices of many terrorist organizations). 33. Osama bin Laden received over $300 million from an inheritance and has acted as a successful businessman by working with groups seeking political or social influence. See Hudson, supra note 3 (finding that only the leadership of Arab terrorist organizations hail from the middle and upper classes). 34. See Telhami, supra note 6, at 587 (indicating that [tlo succeed, terror organizers, regardless of their aims, need to recruit willing members, raise funds, and appeal to public opinion in pursuit of their political objectives. Public despair and humiliation are often fertile ground for terror organizers to exploit. If this demand side persists, the terrorism phenomenon is unlikely to be contained. ) 35. KEN BOOTH & TIM DUNNE, Worlds in Collision, in WORLDS IN COLLISION: TERROR AND THE FUTURE OF GLOBAL ORDER 9 (Ken Booth & Tim Dunne eds., 2002). 36. See Telhami, supra note 6, at 587 (suggesting that terrorist leaders such as Osama bin Laden do not use their personal goals to recruit new members, but rather highlight the issues that resonate with the public and that explain more fully the sense of despair and humiliation among Arabs and Muslims: the Arab- Israeli issue and sanctions against Iraq. ). 37. See, e.g., Walker Interview, supra note 5 (explaining that the gap has actually increased in the region between the rich and the poor. I do believe that there is a link, although not a direct one, between poverty and terrorism. Most of the terrorists are not impoverished. Most of them are frustrated, people who come from the 2004] TERRORISM, DEVELOPMENT & TRADE 595 economic circumstances is an Islamic belief structure that advocates living a just and moral life. 38 Unfortunately for the victims of terrorist attacks, the
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks